Since Filippo has graciously allowed me to post this episode on my website, I encourage you to check out the rest of his show at LifeChangesNetwork.com.
What right does the government have to make you buy health insurance?
It seems obvious at first. Freedom is lack of coercion. Therefore, anything the government makes you do infringes on your freedom.
But there are different types of coercion, and the government isn’t the only one doing the coercing.
Let’s say that you want your daughter to attend the best school in America. But you can’t afford the tuition. Do you really have freedom of choice? If you choose the school you want, they won’t let you through the front door. If you force your way in, they’ll arrest you.
So you “choose” a more affordable school. You wanted a better school, but they forced you to settle for a different one. Sounds like coercion to me.
Let’s consider another example. You want to retire at the age of 65. You’ve worked hard throughout your entire adult life. Unfortunately, wages haven’t risen, and the bills kept piling up. You saved as much as you could, but it’s only enough to live off for a couple years. Oh, and one more thing: Social Security and Medicare don’t exist.
If you “choose” to retire, you’ll go broke. You’ll go without preventive health care. Your chances of dying early will increase significantly.
So you have a choice: Keep working or die young.
In this case, you actually have less freedom because the government is less involved. Without Social Security and Medicare, you do not have the freedom to choose a long, healthy retirement.
Jobs are scarce. Most of us don’t have the freedom to work anywhere we want. We take what we can get. For many of us, that means working at a company that doesn’t pay for our health insurance. So we “choose” to buy insurance on the individual market.
Before Obamacare, the individual market charged really low rates to healthy people and really high rates to sick people. So the people who needed insurance the most couldn’t afford it. They didn’t have the capability — and therefore the freedom — to buy it.
Obamacare outlaws that kind of discrimination. It requires insurers to charge the same rates to healthy and sick people alike, and that means that healthy people will have to pay higher rates. Some of them won’t want to, so they’ll stop buying insurance. When they drop out, they leave behind the sicker people who are most costly to insure, forcing insurers to raise rates even more. It’s a vicious cycle, a “death spiral,” that results in almost everyone being priced out of the market.
Virtually no one will have the freedom to buy health insurance on the individual market.
The government gives them a freedom that the free market cannot. It gives them the capability to purchase health insurance.
If we choose not to buy insurance, we pay a penalty. As Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts has written, “it makes going without insurance just another thing the Government taxes, like buying gasoline or earning income.” Those taxes pay for our roads and Army and Navy and Social Security and Medicare — and those things give us the freedom to live a life that we often take for granted. Without those taxes, without those government-funded investments, we could not call ourselves a free country.
In the same way, without Obamacare, without the government making us buy health insurance, we would be condemning millions of Americans to lives without health care. We would be restricting their freedom. And what right do we have to do that?
Available in e-book format from Lulu Press, Inc:
Available in Kindle format at Amazon.com:
What It’s All About…
Letter to the One Percent is exactly what it sounds like: a letter to the richest one percent of American households. It is a call to action, a plea for compassion, and a manifesto for the future. It tells the story of their extraordinary success — and how the other 99 percent of Americans missed out. It explains how this divergence caused household income to stagnate, forced millions of Americans into poverty, and triggered the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression. It appeals to the better angels of their nature to bear a higher burden — by paying higher taxes, empowering labor, and cracking down on white-collar crime — in order to reverse the damage done in the past three decades.
No other writer has dared to speak these truths directly to power. Every other mainstream book preaches to the choir. Only Letter to the One Percent is brave enough to challenge the rich to do what the country needs them to do. It is not an attack. It is not class warfare. On the contrary: It is a challenge to end the class war that the One Percent has been winning and the 99 Percent has been losing.
No other political subject is as timely as this one. No other economic trend is as pivotal. From the financial crisis in 2008, to Occupy Wall Street in 2010, to the presidential election in 2012, the divergence between the One Percent and the 99 Percent has been the most talked-about issue in American current events. And yet, no one has synthesized the causes and consequences of it in a succinct, yet comprehensive, book. No one has translated the protests and the politics into the simple pocketbook impact that it has had on the average American household. This is the biggest story of our time, and Letter to the One Percent is the first book to tell it fully, accurately, and unflinchingly.
Advance Praise for Letter to the One Percent
“In just 85 pages, the brilliant young economist Anthony W. Orlando analyzes the events of the past thirty-five years and thoroughly explores the rise of the One Percent at the expense of the rest of us. It is truly a manifesto for the 99 Percent and should be read by every one of us.”
— Reese Schonfeld, founding President and CEO of CNN
“Letter to the One Percent is an excellent primer and refresher course on macroeconomics. It helped me understand why the U.S. is experiencing the current economic state of affairs. It is also a compassionate call to action. At first, one may not agree with the basic thesis, but it makes complete sense. I am now a believer and highly recommend this read.”
— Mark Itkin, Co-Head of Worldwide Television at William Morris Endeavor
“Anthony W. Orlando has written a short dossier and critique of America’s descent into a very troubled and vulnerable society. He presents it in the original form of a letter chastising the One Percent for these policy failures and urging them to get hold of themselves and opt for decency and long-run survival. But he also provides a small storehouse of ammunition for the 99 Percent to use in their self-defense.”
— Edward S. Herman, Professor Emeritus of Finance at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, bestselling co-author of Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media
“Anthony W. Orlando has the unique ability to translate complex economic phenomena into everyday, nuts-and-bolts language. He speaks for a brave new generation with a voice that deserves to be heard.”
— Susan M. Wachter, Professor of Real Estate and Finance at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, former Assistant Secretary of the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development
“…this well-researched, carefully cited book is a valuable resource for understanding how the country got in such a perilous position and what can be done about it. Using a clear, authoritative writing style,…Orlando…manages to present an impressive number of facts without overwhelming readers. In particular, the statistics he presents are startling, even for those who closely follow the state of the economy.”
— Kirkus Reviews